Public Employees, Unions and Lithuania

Wonder exactly where Lithuania is? I guess somewhere in Europe. But Lithuania may be closer — at least symbolically — to Wisconsin, Ohio and other states than we might think.

Here’s why.

In case you’ve been focused on the myriad problems involving Lindsay Lohan and Charlie Sheen and missed this, there is a European-style controversy brewing right here in the USA.

And it involves public employees, unions, government spending and state and local politics. Wow. A blogger’s wet dream come true. Oops. I digress.

Here’s from NPR, “Wisconsin is ground zero for battle over unions“:

Wisconsin’s effort to cut public workers’ benefits and bargaining rights has quickly turned into a high-stakes national issue involving President Obama, congressional Republicans and other states.

Wisconsin is the first in a long line of states under Republican control that will consider requiring government workers to pay more for pensions and health care while limiting the power of employee unions to negotiate contracts and work rules.

Ohio is next, likely to vote within weeks on an equally dramatic limit on public employee rights. Arizona, Florida, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, New Hampshire, New Jersey and New Mexico are among the two dozen other states considering narrower but substantial changes in how government treats its workforce.

The moves are aimed at saving hundreds of millions of dollars and cutting the burden of pension and health care costs at a time when state and local government finances are weak.

An aside: In Wisconsin the situation apparently is so dicey that real leadership is required — so a number of Democratic lawmakers fled the state yesterday to prevent a vote. Wonder if those lawmakers are among those criticizing teachers who are calling in sick. Oops. I digress again.

Anyway, a similar protest although on a smaller scale took place yesterday in Ohio where supporters and opponents of a bill to restrict collective bargaining rights met toe-to-toe in Columbus.

So, what’s up with Lithuania?

Well, Lithuania, like many — most? — countries in Europe has promised way more to public employees and most everyone else than they can ever pay for now in terms of pensions, health care and so on. And cutting back is, well, a bitch — with people hitting the concrete in Lithuania, Greece, Spain, France, England and elsewhere.

Here’s from a NYT story, “From Lithuania, A View of Austerity’s Costs“:

VILNIUS, Lithuania — If leaders of the world’s many indebted countries want to see what austerity looks like, they might want to visit this Baltic nation of 3.3 million.

Faced with rising deficits that threatened to bankrupt the country, Lithuania cut public spending by 30 percent — including slashing public sector wages 20 to 30 percent and reducing pensions by as much as 11 percent. Even the prime minister, Andrius Kubilius, took a pay cut of 45 percent.

And the government didn’t stop there. It raised taxes on a wide variety of goods, like pharmaceutical products and alcohol. Corporate taxes rose to 20 percent, from 15 percent. The value-added tax rose to 21 percent, from 18 percent.

The net effect on this country’s finances was a savings equal to 9 percent of gross domestic product, the second-largest fiscal adjustment in a developed economy, after Latvia’s, since the credit crisis began.

But austerity has exacted its own price, in social and personal pain.

Pensioners, their benefits cut, swamped soup kitchens. Unemployment jumped to a high of 14 percent, from single digits — and an already wobbly economy shrank 15 percent last year.

Sweet Maria. Note to Ohio Gov John Kasich: If I end up having to go to a soup kitchen, could it at least serve a nice lobster bisque?  Just askin’.

OK. The issue with state governments, government spending and public service employees and unions really speaks to a big and serious national problem — and we need some thoughtful leadership.

Some key, although I’m sure certainly not all, points:

  • Most states are in deep doo-doo financially. And as best I can tell, unlike the federal government, piling one big budget deficit on top of another is not an alternative.
  • Everybody wants state and local government services — police, fire, education and so on — but nobody really wants to pay, certainly not in the form of higher taxes.
  • The Obama/Pelosi stimulus money — to the extent you can find where it went at all — went in large measure to maintain jobs of teachers and public service employees. Can’t imagine that under current conditions Inside the Beltway that a similar bailout will happen again.
  • There used to be a social contract between local governments and public service employees — certainly with teachers. You would trade lower wages for job security, benefits and fixed pensions. Those days are over, or certainly about to change radically. And full disclosure: I believe teachers, particularly in public K-12 education, are pathetically underpaid.
  • But the perception of those working in the private sector these days — those without employer-provided pensions and with little or no job security if they have a job at all — is that public service employees from the federal government on down have it much better. And it’s hard to argue with that. If you’re sitting there trying to figure out how to retire on your personal savings — now with little if any home equity — and a 401k account that treads water at best, well, good luck for the golden years.

So, we need to pay attention to what is happening in Wisconsin, Ohio and other states — and we need some leadership on these tough problems and issues soon.

Otherwise, we are going to end up understanding a lot more about Lithuania, and that’s a lesson we aren’t going to enjoy.


2 responses to “Public Employees, Unions and Lithuania

  1. With all do respect, I think you are seeing leadership on these tough issues.
    Of all states, wisconsin elected a Rebulican(gasp) governor to do exactly what he pledged to do during his campagin…close a 3.6 billion budget hole.I really feel for the public service employee’s who are being asked to pay less than half of what I pay for my health care and retirement.
    The age of publc sevice unions demanding, and crying, and whining about having to actually support themselves instead of off the public dime is coming to an end, the same as all the other socialist states in europe have realized. The riots in greece are really no different than those in Madison..those people feel entitled to what they receivce and they are not going to give it back without a fight. . They would rather lose their job (which they will) than back away from their Right to have someone else pay for their health care or retirement.
    If our Dear Leader was being truthful about what he said last week when he unvailed his budget, “we all have to learn to live within our means” then you would expect him to be supporting the republican govenor instead of unleashing his attack dog “activist” groups (i.e unions) to flood Madison.
    Actually, since it is a state issue, the president should not have an opinion at all…but why let a little thing like the constitution get in the way of going to bat for for his most loyal fan base!

    • Mark, Hi. Check out Michelle Malkin’s recent blog post. Many agree with you.

      And I agree that the Wisconsin gov is demonstrating leadership — based on what he believes is best for the state. Somebody, maybe it was John McCain, said that elections do have consequences.

      I issue here is in expectations. We want the full range of public services — and we want excellent teachers — and so on. At some point we either reduce those expectations, raise taxes, or grow the economy to the point where there is adequate revenue at all levels of government. Right now, it doesn’t seem as though any of the three are going to happen quickly, easily, or at all.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s